He had our whole army in his power. Instead, Howe stood down just as a storm blew in on August 28th and kept the British fleet from entering the East River. The drenching rain gave Washington time to orchestrate a daring evacuation. The following night, under the cover of thick fog, boats crewed by a regiment of fishermen, smugglers, and seamen from Marblehead, Massachusetts, began ferrying 9,000 soldiers across the East River to Manhattan. Washington himself was the last to leave. And when dawn broke, the British discovered that the Americans had vanished. Despite their crushing defeat, Washington had pulled off a miraculous retreat, and his army lived to fight another day. The next two weeks brought a lull in the fighting, during which General Howe hoped the Americans would come to their senses and negotiate a peace. To that end, on September 11th, his brother Admiral Richard Howe invited Benjamin Franklin, John Adams, and South Carolina's Edward Rutledge to meet with him at the home of a Staten Island loyalist. Over a meal of mutton, ham, and wine, the Admiral offered a truce, insisting, if America should fail, I should feel and lament it like the loss of a brother. With a wry grin, Franklin replied, we will do our utmost endeavors to save your lordship that mortification. The talks broke down when the Americans insisted on a full recognition of United States sovereignty. House Secretary summarized the day by writing, they met, they talked, they parted, and now nothing remains but to fight it out. Then, four days after this fruitless meeting, the British renewed their offensive, landing thousands of troops at Kipps Bay on Manhattan Island. As the British seized control, panic spread through the Continental Army. Entire regiments threw down their muskets in the face of the British invaders. Washington tried and failed to get his troops to make a stand, even swatting at passing soldiers with his sword, a futile attempt to stop them from fleeing. He cried out, Good God, have I got such troops as these? But facing this chaotic retreat, Washington withdrew his army north to Harlem Heights, where his soldiers rallied and drove back a British detachment, a minor clash but a badly needed morale boost. Meanwhile, as the British took over New York City, patriots fled and loyalists poured back in from the surrounding countryside. Soon, hundreds of loyalists signed oaths affirming their allegiance to the king, and for the rest of the war, New York became Britain's primary stronghold in America. But just days after the British occupation, a massive nighttime fire destroyed a quarter of the city. No one knew the cause, but British officials suspected rebel arsonists. Soldiers captured and executed suspects on the spot as thousands of residents fled the burning city, and those who remained faced a devastating housing and food crisis. But for now, the main theater of the war shifted away from New York as the British chased Washington's battered army across the Hudson to New Jersey. And after Washington's poor showing in Manhattan, a new rival emerged a challenge to the general's leadership,